RV Propane Furnace vs. Electric: What’s Right for Your RV?

RV Propane Furnace vs. Electric: What’s Right for Your RV?

Choosing the proper heating source for your RV is a critical decision for ensuring comfort in colder weather while on the road. Whether you’re parked under a starry desert sky on a cool night or cruising through snow-covered mountain ranges, your heating system should meet your specific needs. RV enthusiasts often face the age-old question of propane furnaces versus electric heating systems. This post dives into the key factors to help you decide which is right for your RV.

Fuel Efficiency

Let’s start by looking at the efficiency of each system. Propane furnaces have maintained a solid reputation for their high heating efficiency over the years. Typically, these systems can generate intense heat relatively quickly, making them ideal for harsh, cold environments. Plus, propane is stored in liquid form within onboard tanks, which are easy to refill at most campgrounds, dedicated propane refill stations, or even some gas stations.

However, the efficiency of a propane furnace depends primarily on the insulation of your RV and the furnace’s age. Older systems may lose efficiency due to wear and tear, while newer models come with advanced technology designed to improve performance and energy use. That said, propane furnaces heat up space significantly faster than electric ones, thanks to their high BTU (British Thermal Unit) output.

On the other side of things, electric heating systems for RVs are commonly praised for their consistent energy use and efficiency. Unlike propane, which can sometimes leave residual energy loss due to imperfect combustion, electric heaters convert almost all electrical energy directly into heat. If you’re staying in campgrounds equipped with electrical hookups, you won’t have to rely on any battery or generator usage. This efficient nature makes them a popular choice for long-term stays at powered sites.

However, electric heating systems typically fare better in small RVs or less extreme weather, as their heating capacity is not as robust compared to propane systems. For larger RVs or regions with very low temperatures, electric heating may struggle to provide uniform warmth across all areas.

Cost Analysis

RV Propane Furnace vs. Electric: What’s Right for Your RV?

No matter which heating system you get, they’ll carry both upfront and ongoing costs. The initial installation of a propane furnace can range anywhere from $1,000 to $2,000, depending on the brand and capacity. From there, regular propane refills are an inevitable expense. On average, propane costs around $2.50-$4.00 per gallon, and the amount consumed depends on both the furnace’s BTU rating and how often it’s in use.

For extended trips, these refills can add up quickly, especially in cold conditions where the furnace is running consistently. It’s worth noting, however, that propane-filled bases in remote locations often charge less than in urban areas, making this a feasible option for adventurers venturing out to nature.

One of the reasons electric heating systems have grown in popularity partially is due to their cost-effectiveness in a variety of circumstances. If you’re staying at an RV park or campground offering flat-rate electricity as part of their rental fees, an electric heater allows you to heat the interior without additional expenses—a significant advantage over propane systems. Electric heater models themselves are also relatively inexpensive, often costing between $40 and $300.

That said, reliance on electric heating can become expensive when relying solely on generators in off-grid locations. The energy consumption of electric heaters is high, which could mean churning through considerable fuel to keep your generator running—an often overlooked cost.

Environmental Impact

A concern for many RV enthusiasts is the potential environmental impact of their vehicles. Both heating systems vary a bit here, but both are still good options in this regard. For instance, propane is regarded as one of the least environmentally harmful fossil fuels. It burns cleanly and produces fewer greenhouse gas emissions compared to gasoline or diesel. However, since propane is still a non-renewable resource, it does have some environmental impact, including energy used during its extraction and refinement.

Outside of general usage, one aspect to consider is propane leakage. While infrequent, it releases unburned propane into the atmosphere, which could have a more potent greenhouse effect than CO2. Proper maintenance of your propane system is thus essential to minimize environmental harm.

Because of these minor issues, electric heaters are often hailed as the more environmentally friendly option. However, this assumes that the electricity that is powering them comes from renewable sources. If you’re staying at an RV park connected to solar, wind, or hydropower grids, your carbon footprint is essentially nonexistent.

Off-grid users relying on generators, however, face a different story. Fossil-fuel-based generators can negate the environmental benefits of choosing an electric heater. Additionally, electric heaters require heavy energy consumption compared to lower BTU-releasing propane alternatives.

Performance in Varying Weather Conditions

While heat is something you only really need when it’s cold out, it’s still important to know how these systems operate in varying weather conditions. For example, propane furnaces excel in cold climates, delivering rapid heat that can cut through even the harshest winter chill. Thanks to their high BTU output, these systems distribute heat evenly across larger RVs, ensuring that no corners go untouched. They’re particularly reliable for extended adventures in alpine areas or during the winter season.

Electric heating, while steady in its performance, struggles to match propane furnaces in extreme weather scenarios. Most electric heaters on the market have limited BTU outputs compared to propane models, requiring more time to achieve warm temperatures, especially in larger or poorly insulated RVs. However, in mild climates or smaller RVs, electric systems offer a cozy, consistent heat that works perfectly without being overpowering.

Considerations for Choosing the Right System

RV Propane Furnace vs. Electric: What’s Right for Your RV?

Of course, knowing the differences between RV propane furnaces and electric heating systems is only half the battle. You still need to be able to decide which system will work best for your personal needs. While this decision is ultimately up to you, we have a couple of tips to help you decide which RV furnace you should get.

Size and Layout of the RV

The size and layout of your RV play a massive role in determining which heating system is ideal. If you own a larger RV with multiple rooms, a propane furnace may prove more effective at distributing heat evenly. Electric heaters are better suited for smaller RVs or single-room designs where their heating range can comfortably cover the entire space.

Frequency of Use and Duration of Trips

For seasonal adventurers who undertake shorter trips or camp during moderate weather conditions, electric heating systems might work just fine. However, full-time RVers or those planning extended winter road trips would likely find propane systems more dependable in their ability to sustain heat over prolonged periods.

Personal Preferences and Comfort

Lastly, consider your personal preferences for comfort and convenience. Some RVers appreciate the powerful heat and independence offered by propane systems, while others prioritize the cost-saving advantages and eco-friendliness of electric heaters. Also, some of you might simply not get as cold as the average person. No matter the reason, decide what matters most to your lifestyle to make the best investment for you and your needs.

Comments (0)

There are no comments for this article. Be the first one to leave a message!

Leave a comment

Please note: comments must be approved before they are published